Saturday, October 5, 2002

Smokies, Foothills Parkway Mountain Biking, 10-5-2002

My preferences for places to enjoy the outdoors rarely change. I love the Smokies and Cumberland mountains for hiking, running, and exploring off trail, and cherish the many parks around Knoxville for shorter trips on the bike and on foot. And I’ve run the West Hills and Tenmile Greenways near home a couple of times a week for decades. But sometimes my tastes do change, and courses that were once solid favorites can fall completely off the radar. One of those lost and “almost forgotten” routes is the section of the Foothills Parkway east of US 321 near Walland.

Welcome to the Foothills Parkway.

I’d lived in Knoxville for six years before I headed out there for a run, and wouldn’t return for another three years to try it on the bike. But something clicked and the Parkway (including the western section from US321 to US 129 past Look Rock) became one of my favorite places to ride and hike for an intense three-year stretch. After that I’ve made a few trips, but the Parkway has changed so much that I hardly recognize my old friend.

The gate at the US 321 access to the Parkway.

Current Knoxvillians may not believe it, but when I first moved to the area in 1993 neither trail running nor mountain biking were popular activities. I was used to having a million acres of national forest roads and trails out my back door, but there were few places nearby Knoxville with the distance, surface, and scenery for good mountain biking. There wasn’t much help from guidebooks in the 1990s either, though I would eventually help fill that gap with my own backroad bicycling guide for the Smokies and Blue Ridge areas Guide.

What information existed then was on the East Tennessee Mountain Bike section of Tom Dunigan’s Tennessee Landforms website. (TN Landforms)

The SMHC trip to the snowy Parkway.

1-3-99, “Trail” Run

East Tennessee Mountain Bike was a bare bones site, but it had all the info needed to plan a ride serious or otherwise. I’d read through the site, but never tried the Foothills Parkway section until January 3, 1999 after I drove Jean to the airport for a conference and I was looking for somewhere to run close by in the Smokies. At that time, we referred to the section to the west of US 321 (formally sections 8G and 8H) as the “Look Rock” section, and the uncompleted section (formally sections 8E and 8F) to the east as the “Closed” or “Gated” section. The NPS allowed hikers, cyclists, and horseback riders on the closed section, but kept it closed to motor vehicles except on special occasions, such as fall leaf viewing.

Jean and a rare Tennessee snowman.

I knew little about the Parkway then and was surprised to find the road was paved, but rough in places. The first three miles were a serious climb before the grade lessened. I went about seven miles roundtrip in 66 minutes, turning around at a survey marker after completing the first big climb. There were great views south toward the Little River and across to the Smokies foothills. I couldn’t help but notice the rocky roadcuts with strong iron staining among the shales and sandstones. The weather was clear and calm and around 20-25F. I saw one other pair of hikers, first timers as well. The Look Rock section was also closed that day.

On the Look Rock section of the Parkway.

10-5-02, Bike Ride

Despite having such an enjoyable inaugural run, I did not return to the Parkway until late 2002. At that time, I was writing my biking guide and was looking to achieve a balance of locations and conditions for rides. I planned to include the Look Rock section in the book and then briefly describe the closed section as an alternative or addition to the Look Rock Section. I’d already ridden the west section (a 35-mile round trip twice over the top of Look Rock) when I headed to the closed section on October 5, 2002.

The Look Rock section was in good shape, and I usually used my road bike there. The closed section was rougher, and I suspect I used my mountain bike, but didn’t record which bike I was on for any of my rides on the Parkway. For the ride I made a detailed road log, noting all the features that a curious rider might encounter, and took the picture that would be used in my book to illustrate the ride.

From the dirt parking area at the gate across the Parkway it was a quarter mile to the end of the bridge over US 321, The first climb is a doozy, about 760’ in the next 2.5 miles. A pair of pullouts with views over Tuckaleechee Cove provide excuses for pulling over to rest. This was what it was all about; a remote mountain road with an easy surface, lots of views, and no cars(!), things don’t get much better. Once on the crest of the foothills the riding is gentler on what the quad sheet calls Bates Mountain. There was one large pullout used to store materials for the road builders, and another pair of overlooks.

The shallow overlook at 4.8 miles marks the start of the descent to the Carr Creek Bridge. This is a good spot for those looking for an easy day to turn around. In the next mile and a half, the road drops 520 hard earned feet. Beyond the Carr Creek Bridge the road climbs steadily, twists past a pair of overlooks, and gains another 1,000 feet. At about 9.3 miles, near Caylor Gap, there is a spacious overlook. In 2002, (and again in 2004) two huge bridges beyond led to the end of the road at a berm at 9.8 miles marking the end of the 1980s era road building. According to Dunnigan, “There is 1.8 miles of technical single track in the middle with steep pitches and one rocky push” to connect to the completed road on the Wears Cove side. I never explored the 1.8-mile single track connector nor the completed roadway (4.1 miles long according to Dunnigan) on the Wears Cove side.

The substantial vertical on this ride was ideal for bike climbing training. My friend Mark was especially eager to polish his climbing skills on this route and made it a regular ride.

I came less frequently but often enough to get lazy in my record keeping making at least three trips with only a note that I’d ridden the Parkway and my mileage. But on 7-7-2004 I did another ride making a GPS track and taking waypoints. At the far end of the first bridge was a memorial to Roger Bonneteau, “A construction of the highest order,” who was killed working on the bridge on 8-10-2000.

1-19-03, Hiking Trip

In addition to biking on the Parkway we found it a good location for hiking on snow days, especially when we were looking for hikes close to home. Jean’s first trip was on 1-19-03 and featured three inches of new snow. We hiked about nine miles, probably out and back to the start of the downhill to Carr Creek. We almost always saw other people on the Parkway. This time we saw three other groups. I took some black and white prints, hoping to be able to use those for my biking guide. The snow was thick enough that we could see ski tracks heading up the unplowed Look Rock section of the Parkway. In those conditions we’d find US 321 well maintained even when it was impossible to get around in the main part of the park.

Jean and I on the Parkway.

We would repeat the snow hike on 12-12-04. This time we found one of the access points from private property leading to the “blue house that was visible from the Parkway”. In January of 2006 Jean’s SMHC hike to Rich Mountain in Cades Cove was snowed out, so we substituted another trip to the closed section. Our final hike was 12-20-09, and featured a visit from a group of friendly llamas of unknown origin.

Llamas on the Parkway!

The Walland to Wears Cove sections (8E and 8F) were completed and opened in November 2018. Like the adjacent sections (8G and 8H) from Walland to Chilhowee Lake, the new Parkway is lightly used by sightseers, and the few cyclists willing to battle the long climbs and to share the road with distracted drivers and aggressive motor cyclists. Jean and I have only driven the new section twice, once shortly after the opening and again supporting a recent hike. The Parkway takes some extra time compared to the highway through Townsend, and is more scenic, but requires some vigilance in dodging motorbikes.

Our own interest in the Parkway has come full circle. The next stage in the development of the Parkway is section 8D from Wears Valley to the Gatlinburg Spur. The first step in the proposed project is a mountain bike trail system within the Wears Valley portion of Foothills Parkway. A plan has been approved, but not funded, that will develop 12 miles of trails plus build another mile of the Parkway in the area just north of Metcalf Bottoms. No work has been done on the project since it was approved in May 2022. We enlisted our friend Ed to join us in exploring the property where the trails are planned. Though well intentioned, the project was a response to demand for mountain biking trails on the north side of the Smokies that has since been answered by commercial areas developed at Vee Hollow (Vee Hollow) in Townsend, Wildside (Wildside) in Pigeon Forge, and at Ober Mountain in Gatlinburg, not to mention the extensive system at the Urban Wilderness in South Knoxville.

More alarmingly, the planning for completing the Parkway section of 8D is underway with public scoping conducted in late fall of 2023 and early 2024. The NPS and Federal Highway Administration originally completed baseline studies and preliminary designs for Section 8D between the late 1980s and early 1990s to develop a draft Environmental Impact Statement in 1994. They propose to use this outdated information to complete 9 miles of Parkway, including a 1,200-foot tunnel. Though there are various options for connecting the Parkway into the Gatlinburg Spur, there are no alternatives to a full build of the Parkway, despite considerable local enthusiasm for converting the Parkway Corridor to a system of hiker/biker trails that would be easily accessible to the local community.

Most tellingly, there is no mention of cost estimates for the project. The completion of the missing link between Walland and Wears Valley was a financial boondoggle, with individual bridges costing over $12 million and costs through 2013 of nearly $100 million. A biking/hiking trail would easily cost less than a tenth of that and would fit more appropriately with the park’s mission.

Here is a summary of Foothills Parkway history prior to the closure of the Missing Link in 2018.

Partial Foothills Parkway Timeline.

Here’s an overview of the FHP and details for the proposal for section 8D.

Foothills Parkway Project Overview.